May 28, 2003
Liberals will let ROH expansion 'go
McGuinty wants hospitals to stay in public hands
The Ottawa Citizen
Wednesday, May 28, 2003
Despite his vow to scrap public-private sector partnerships in health
Liberal leader Dalton McGuinty says the Royal Ottawa Hospital's planned
$100-million expansion will go ahead.
Mr. McGuinty told the Citizen that the Liberal party understands very
the need for a new mental health facility in Ottawa to serve Eastern
and would do nothing to jeopardize the project, which is to be built
combination of public and private funds. He said all such projects
under way in the province would not be cancelled.
However, he said a Liberal government would explore every opportunity to
return such hospitals to public hands.
"Those are projects that are important to the communities and we
the need. The projects will go ahead," he said.
"What I take issue with is the mechanism. We believe in public ownership
public financing (of health care). I will take these hospitals and bring
them inside the public sector."
Mr. McGuinty warned recently that if the Liberals are elected in the
provincial election now expected in the fall, they will stop private
financing of hospitals, the so-called P3s, which the Conservative
is pushing as the way of the future.
Mr. McGuinty believes that public-private sector partnerships in health
would ultimately cost the province more money than traditional
He says such arrangements would be discontinued and the hospitals
to full public ownership.
In effect, the Liberals plan to buy them back. He said, however, that a
Liberal government would not rush to end these arrangements to ensure
taxpayers are not saddled with heavy financial penalties.
Despite the assurances, the Liberal policy has raised concerns in
where the ROH is only weeks away from announcing a private-public sector
partnership under which a developer will build a new state-of-the-art
health centre and lease it back to the hospital. The ROH board has
the winning consortium and approved design of the new hospital.
Still, George Langill, president and CEO of the ROH, says he prefers the
approach. He says a public-private sector partnership will allow the ROH
save money, sidestep the need to raise its share of capital costs worth
about $20 million, and help build the hospital much more quickly.
"We have an opportunity to pioneer a new approach to capital
is a better approach than the traditional way. I am hoping that politics
isn't the reason we have to divert from this," Mr. Langill said at a
with the Citizen editorial board yesterday.
He said capital requirements for Ontario hospitals now top $8 billion
an era when governments do not have billions of dollars to spare,
public-private sector partnerships offer the best hope for capital
"No matter how well-intentioned Mr. McGuinty is to do things through the
traditional approach, there is just no money to do everything. Eight
dollars is a lot of money to find without putting Ontario in a deficit,"
The Conservative government announced plans for Ontario's first
built and owned hospitals in Brampton and Ottawa two years ago. The $350
million William Osler Health Centre in Brampton and the new ROH would be
built by private capital and leased to the hospitals.
Private-sector investors will run everything from the physical plant to
services such as food and maintenance. The hospitals will be responsible
Under the plan, a private consortium will build a new mental health
on the 10-hectare site on Carling Avenue. Other commercial development,
as stores, doctors' offices and possibly housing will fill the rest of
The ROH will enter into a 66-year lease with the developer, but within
24 years, the main building would revert to ROH ownership because it
have been paid for. At the end of the 66 years, the entire site would be
owned by ROH.
Plans for a new mental hospital began in 1999, when a consultant
that renovating the existing hospital would cost $115 million.
would take about seven years and future maintenance costs would remain
But with a new hospital costing $100 million, the hospital took that
© Copyright 2003 The Ottawa Citizen